Huntley Wealth Insurance | Instant Term Life Insurance Quotes!

Term life insurance policies for individuals with high risk medical conditions. For term or whole life, we're the experts.

  • FREE QUOTE
Menu
  • Life Insurance
    • Life Insurance Basics
      • How Much I Need
      • How Much it Costs
      • How do I Buy Life Insurance?
      • What is Term Life Insurance?
      • Best Life Insurance Companies
    • Types of Life Insurance
      • Term Life Insurance
      • Whole Life Insurance
      • No Exam Life Insurance
      • Universal Life Insurance
    • Sample Quotes by Age
      • 20 to 29 Years Old
      • 30 to 39 Years Old
      • 40 to 49 Years Old
      • 50 to 59 Years Old
      • 60 to 69 Years Old
      • 70 to 75 Years Old
      • Other
    • Pre-existing Conditions
      • High Blood Pressure
      • High Cholesterol
      • Overweight
      • Diabetes
      • Cigarette Smokers
      • Cigar, Pipe and Chewing Tobacco
      • Sleep Apnea
      • Prostate Cancer or Enlarged Prostate
      • Crohn’s Disease
      • Skin Cancer
    • Close
  • Car Insurance
    • Auto Insurance Basics
      • Best Auto Insurance Companies
      • Cheap Car Insurance Quotes
      • Average Cost
      • Car Insurance Calculator
      • Find An Agent
    • Types of Auto Insurance
      • Classic Car Insurance
      • Commercial Insurance
      • Sports Car Insurance
    • Sample Quotes
      • Find Your Make/Model
      • Find Your State/City
    • Close
  • Homeowners Insurance
  • Pet Insurance
  • All Types of Insurance

Rejected Life Insurance Payout for “Suicide by Cop” Case

By Chris Huntley

Do life insurance really pay out their claims?

While my typical answer is a resounding “Yes,” rare denial stories like the one below do happen.

In this article, we’ll cover why this widow’s payout was rejected and what we can learn from this.

Related Stories

  • 7 Life Insurance Payouts Gone Wrong
  • How to Avoid a Declined Payout During the 2 Year Contestability Period
  • What Heath Ledger’s Death Taught Us About Lying on an Application

Utah Widow’s Payout Rejected in Husband’s Cop Shooting Case

American General Life Insurance Company steadfastly maintains its refusal to pay out on a life insurance claim to the widow of the man shot by police in Centreville, Utah.

Here’s how the story unfolds.

Vincent Farrand took out a life insurance policy with AIG in 2011 with a face value of $500,000.

He named his wife Molly Farrand as beneficiary.

In 2014, which was 3 years later, police were called to the couple’s residence. Mr. Farrand appeared to be intoxicated and was carrying a handgun. Police allege they told him several times to drop the weapon.

While walking toward a gate in the backyard, police contend he continued to carry the gun and was mumbling something similar to ‘Shoot me. You’re going to have to shoot me.’ Farrand was eventually shot and killed by police.

The autopsy of Mr. Farrand also revealed that he had 0.21% alcohol content at the time of his death.

Molly Farrand contends that her husband was in the process of lowering the weapon. It should be noted that it is legal to carry a handgun in Utah because it is an ‘open carry’ state. She filed a civil action against Centreville for $2 million dollars.

The municipality settled out of court for $127,000 but made clear that it did so with no admission of fault of the part of the police officer.

Ms. Farrand submitted her life insurance claim to American General who denied the claim.

In a letter to her dated August 18, 2014, the company claimed that her husband was suicidal and legally impaired.

Subsequently, a suit was filed by Ms. Farrand’s attorney for the face amount of the $500,000 life insurance policy.

“Suicide By Cop” – A Tough Decision for an Insurance Claims Department

Many life insurance experts are a bit perplexed by AIG’s refusal to pay the claim.

When does the issue of suicide become an issue?

The majority of life insurance policies clearly include suicide as an exclusion from paying out a claim. The problem is, this exclusion has a 2 year limitation. If an insured commits suicide more than 2 years after the policy came into effect, the life insurer legally has to pay the claim.

Furthermore, why does drunkenness affect a payout?

In this instance, even if Mr. Farrand was trying to commit ‘suicide by cop’, the incident took place 3 years after his life insurance policy came into effect. The gun he was carrying is not relevant because it was his legal right to do so, nor is the fact that he was intoxicated at the time.

The bottom line is, it appears that AIG was in the wrong in these particular circumstances.  They do not appear to have any legal basis for not paying the claim.

Note: One possible explanation for AIG’s refusal would be if this was an accidental policy (which only pay out for accidental deaths.)  In that case, the alcohol and possible suicide would both be grounds for possible denial.

Many readers might think – ‘Well this is typical isn’t it?’

Actually, no.  The majority of life insurers do pay their claims. As with any policy, there are exclusions that apply, such as being untruthful when you apply for life insurance or engaging in an activity which is especially hazardous for example.

If you want to learn more about whether life insurers pay their claims then you should read this article “Do Life Insurance Companies Really Pay Their Claims.”

We think you will be pleasantly surprised!

*While we make every effort to keep our site updated, please be aware that "timely" information on this page, such as quote estimates, or pertinent details about companies, may only be accurate as of its last edit day. Huntley Wealth & Insurance Services and its representatives do not give legal or tax advice. Please consult your own legal or tax adviser.

Filed Under: Articles For Agents

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

About | Blog | Tools | Contact

This website provides information for the reader to choose to request more information about life insurance, including how to apply for a quote.  By requesting a quote, or application for a quote, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms & Conditions. If you submit your personal information, you are making a consumer inquiry for life insurance through us as a licensed insurance producer as more fully described below.  By proceeding, you give your consent and expectation to be contacted by a life insurance producer or company.  Any health or personal information shared is protected by applicable privacy laws and regulations, including HIPAA.

Invitations on insuranceblogbychris.com for application for insurance are made through Consumers Advocate Group, LLC (and in Florida: Consumers Advocate, LLC, and in New York: Consumers Advocate Group of Washington, LLC), an independent agent/producer, and its designated insurance producer, Francine Powel, only where licensed.  All license numbers are available here and automatically provided as required by law.  Consumers Advocate Group, LLC and Francine Powel are licensed insurance producers in all states and the District of Columbia. Partial list of licenses of Consumers Advocate Group, LLC and Francine Powel include National Producer Numbers 17651093 & 17613858, Resident State of Washington 892652 & 889919, Arkansas 100133617 & 17613858, California OK54069 & OK36946, Louisiana 662576 & 661089, Massachusetts 1987330 & 1984318, Minnesota 40439498 & 40437799, Texas 2170808 & 2022858 & 2019069, and Utah 536206 & 534286.

Commercial use by others is prohibited by law. No portion of insuranceblogbychris.com may be copied, published, faxed, mailed or distributed in any manner for any purpose without prior written authorization from the owner.

Insurance policies described, quoted, shown, and illustrated throughout this website are not an offer for the sale of any particular insurance policy or product, only an invitation for application for insurance coverage and may not be relied upon.   There are many variables in different insurance coverages and companies, including various insurance company standards and offerings, underwriting requirements and may not be available in all states.

“Insurance Blog By Chris" is a trademark of Ad Practitioners LLC.

Copyright © 2019 – All Rights Reserved